I don't think you're going to like how this ends...
Well, it was inevitable. It was inevitable that I would have Harry Potter in the final four and it's almost predictable that A Song of Ice and Fire, Wheel of Time, and Lord of the Rings would end up here.
How is it that three of the four series in this round are a direct result of my relationship with The Man? Almost disgusting.
Lord of the Rings lost because it was the first of its genre. Yeah, both have made up languages that were created by the authors, but as Walt Disney is paraphrased, 'keep moving forward'. Dumbledore had to prevail over Gandalf only because Dumbledore, for all his being a wizard, was mortal and lived and loved as such. I don't even know what Gandalf loved other than the status quo of peace.
A Song of Ice and Fire has been consistently great over the course of the entire series. There were books in the Wheel of Time series where I wanted to (insert the most awful thing you can do to baby seals) and really, I could've done without two whole books of Perrin's whingeing about Faile. Oh, and the traveling circus. I have no idea why that was even part of the plot.
Really pretty frickin hard to choose the final winner. I had to sleep on it a couple nights.
Really, what it boiled down to was a point The Man made (and which I agreed with) when we were happily discussing this bracket line-up. For all of it being fiction, A Song of Ice and Fire is highly lacking in the deus ex machina that you have in the Harry Potter series, or the all the rest of the other series for that matter. It's extremely human in that way.
Plus, there's still more to come. We don't yet know how the story ends...but I sure did like how it began. George R. R. Martin kills off his characters...because he doesn't fall in love with them. You think one character is the protagonist? BAM! Beheaded on the steps of the Sept of Baelor. Then you think, okay...so his son's the person the story's really about. BAM! Murdered by treacherous vassals.
I may do this with movies sometime. Who's with me?